Pakistan’s misery is just starting

This is an insightful piece by The Australian which avoids the usual stereotyping and tries to delve deeper into the Pakistani disaster. PTH views have also been quoted – glad to note that we are being heard – Indeed, the Pakistanis and the world must wake up. Raza Rumi

BEFORE US senator John Kerry flew to Pakistan, he told reporters he hoped to help the world understand that the disaster was not just about floods.

“It’s about Pakistan’s ability to move forward and survive this difficult situation,” he said.

The US and the Western world’s most crucial ally in the fight against terrorism is on its knees and it has never been a more dangerous time for the already unstable democratic nation.

Pakistan, already overwhelmed by a serious economic downturn and spiralling Taliban insurgency, is facing the worst natural disaster in more than a century.

The government’s stocks are so low as to be almost subterranean, such is the anger among the populace over its perceived failure to prepare for, then respond adequately to, the crisis.

Pakistan watchers have nervously noted the glorification of the military’s rescue efforts in the past two weeks and the relentless attacks on the country’s democratically elected President, Asif Ali Zardari.

No one has failed to notice the widespread presence of militant charities, among the first to mobilise aid across the worst hit and most remote areas of the unstable northwest. Or that three weeks into this crisis the increasingly desperate pleas for aid — from the government, the UN, the US and from international aid organisations of all stripes — are only now being heard.

The world has been slow to recognise the extent of the disaster and even slower to open its pockets, a combined result perhaps of a relatively low death rate compared with other disasters and an inherent distrust of a country racked by systemic corruption.

So far, donor nations — led by the US — have pledged nearly $US200 million ($213m).

The World Bank yesterday offered a $US900m loan to the debt-laden nation, already $US11 billion in hock to the International Monetary Fund.

One-quarter of the country is inundated. Billions of dollars of infrastructure, agriculture and homes have been washed away and will need to be rebuilt, at a cost the Pakistan government estimates at about $US15bn.

Twenty million people have been affected by the floods, two million are homeless and six million are reliant on government and aid groups for food and water.

UN Office for the Co-ordination of Humanitarian Affairs spokesman Maurizio Giuliano tells The Australian that relief agencies so far have managed to bring clean water to just one million of the six million people in need. “We’re just not able to get enough funding,” he says. “If you only have 30 per cent of the funds you need then how can we buy food and tents?”

While the Pakistan government refuses to acknowledge cholera outbreaks, aid workers say the potentially fatal water-borne disease is evident right across flood-hit areas and the country is facing a second wave of mass deaths. “The people that have been affected are so many that if you don’t act fast enough we could very soon see many more people dying because of lack of clean water, medicines and lack of food,” Giuliano says.

Right now the country cannot cope with a health crisis. Hospitals across flood-ravaged areas have been damaged and medical staff are under serious strain. In Pakistan’s Himalayan region of Gilgit-Baltistan last week, doctors at the only local hospital were working by candlelight. In one case, a new mother’s episiotomy wound was stitched by the weak light of a doctor’s mobile phone.

“In the antenatal and post-partum . . . flies circle beds covered by soiled and wrinkled sheets,” visiting doctor and postdoctoral fellow Emma Varley reports, adding that “without water or power the beds hadn’t been changed in over a week”.

“The pressures placed on this hospital by the needs of an estimated 1.5 million residents are profound.”

On Monday, angry flood survivors in the President’s home province of Sindh took to the streets in protest, demanding more relief. Many more such demonstrations will surely follow.

Food prices have already doubled in markets across the country and are tipped to rise further. Analysts estimate 30 per cent to 40 per cent of the country’s agricultural production has been wiped out.

It does not take a particularly astute observer to understand the ground is ripe for serious political upheaval.

In Pakistan’s short 63-year history there has only been one response to crises: a military coup. Analysts are now fiercely divided over the likelihood of such a scenario. Veteran Pakistan commentator and former military colonel Talat Masood says it is unlikely given the present circumstances.

“As if we didn’t have enough trouble already. That would be a disaster for Pakistan,” he tells The Australian, adding: “There’s nobody thinking of challenging the government because of the floods.

“Obviously the government in the beginning was slow to respond but the magnitude of the devastation was such that even the best of governments would have had difficulty meeting the need.”

Masood says the floods present an opportunity to rebuild Pakistan in a safer, more equitable way and concedes new leadership could well emerge out of the crisis to challenge Pakistan’s moribund political landscape.

“The question is how to transform a great tragedy into a great opportunity,” he says.

“This is an opportunity to build new infrastructure that’s more solid, build houses that are much safer, bridges that are stronger and an economy based on indigenous production. People have gone through something they will never forget and only those governments who can deliver will last.”

Former North-West Frontier Province secretary-general and analyst Rustam Shah Mohmand says a military coup can never be ruled out in a nation that has surrendered to army rule for almost half its history.

“The military is already in the driver’s seat so why should they take over now and accept all the blame for the problems to come,” Mohmand says.

But he adds: “In the past the military [has] brushed aside those calculations and taken over and ruled the country for a major part of its existence, so you can’t completely rule it out.”

A recent survey of 2000 Pakistani adults by the Pew Research Centre’s Global Attitudes Project found just 20 per cent of respondents approved of Zardari while 61 per cent viewed Pakistan army chief Ashfaq Parvez Kayani favourably.

Pakistan commentator and editor of influential cyber-magazine Pak Tea House Raza Rumi also warns of systemic collapse if the needs of millions of poor — and now destitute — Pakistanis are not met soon.

“The people in southern Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa [two areas known for militancy] are extremely angry and frustrated at the inability of the state to act in a timely and purposeful manner, he writes in a PTH blog.

“Jamat-ud-Dawa [the charity arm of banned militant group Lashkar-e-Toiba] is already at the forefront of relief efforts in the Punjab, while several offshoots of the militants’ alliances in the northwest are capitalising on the extraordinary situation that we face today. It is not beyond the realm of possibility that these two parts of Pakistan, already poor, marginalised and victims of state neglect, would see a major swing towards Islamism.”

The floods have caught Pakistan badly off-guard. A year of rolling military operations against Taliban and other extremists in the northwest and tribal border areas had finally started to weaken the insurgency.

The military successes in previous Taliban strongholds, and evidence the security establishment for once was unified in its efforts to rout the extremists, had won it increasingly popular support. But a Marshall plan for the conflict-affected areas had not yet been properly devised or implemented and the floods have turned the clock backwards.

And the hardship has really only just begun. Murtaza Haider, a professor in supply chain management and logistics at Toronto’s Ryerson University, says the price of basic staples has already risen 100 per cent to 200 per cent in the past few weeks as food stocks run dangerously low.

About 7.3 million hectares of productive crop land has been wiped out and, thanks to the country’s limited food storage capacity, it faces the prospect of having to import basic foodstuffs for at least the next year.

“We are going to see a situation where not just the low income but also mid and high-level income households will have a very tough time paying for the food they consume,” Haider tells The Australian.

Even before the floods, the World Food Program assessed 50 per cent of Pakistan’s 170 million people as being “food insecure”. But the convergence of floods, the inflationary effect of the Islamic month of Ramadan and the wheat crisis — which has caused prices to rise 90 per cent since June — could “render a much larger proportion of the Pakistanis unable to secure basic food items at affordable prices”.

“Pakistan has suddenly become even more food insecure while being armed with nuclear weapons,” he says. Haider estimates it will be two years before the mainstream agricultural production cycle is back on track, “so people around the world are going to have to be very generous to Pakistan”.

“The problem is those who were involved in agriculture have been uprooted and it will take some time to resettle them. Then you need time to get seed supplies, farm equipment.

“You look at the tsunami and the Haiti earthquake, the sheer human toll of those events was obvious so quickly, but in Pakistan its the other way around. You could not have saved the people who died in the tsunami but here at least we have a chance.”



Filed under disaster, North-West Frontier Province, Pak Tea House, Pakistan

11 responses to “Pakistan’s misery is just starting

  1. Maryanne Khan

    A very good thing, Raza, and you have the respect of the journalist you quote.

    I’ve been here on PTH bleating that Australia has tried to understand the crisis and does. AUS$35 million is not insignificant. This article published by a traditionally non hysterical, non populist newspaper, The Australian, as you say, rightly, “which avoids the usual stereotyping and tries to delve deeper into the Pakistani disaster” has a readership over here of the more ‘intellectual’ amongst our population. A good thing when a rationalist approach is required to analyse and resolve the problems facing your nation. And yes, how wonderful that PTH has come under their scrutiny.

    Our support is informed and genuine. And by that I mean by journalists (and their intended readers) who are not beating a self-serving gong or one based on discrimination on the basis of race or religion.

    Commentators on PTH, please realise that the wider world is obviously watching what you say, and please lose the divisive, fractious, and weak (politically and morally) arguments based on ‘my religion is better than yours’ attitude.

    It does nothing to help the cause of women swimming floods to save their children and will not plant a single grain of rice or wheat.

    And please don’t accuse me of detached misunderstanding or patronising, I support my village over there and have contributed money during the earthquake and now — and will in the future for the floods.

    I am blessed to live in a country that is economically strong, and the few dollars I can contribute reap many times over the value they represent to me. And I’m happy to send what I can.

  2. Pingback: Pakistan’s misery is just starting -

  3. Midfield Dynamo

    Unfortunately once again it is time for us to beg for help, mostly from those we are striving to destroy at any given opportunity.
    I remember when Ali Bhutto went to China with his entourage in designer suits and silk ties, in those days the Chinese wore drab communist uniforms, in the Peoples Hall one Chinese official remarked ‘Here come the best dressed beggars’.
    Stop begging. Please. Generate resources from within, get those real estate assets in Dubai, the French Rivera or where ever they might be, help your brethren and stop begging….
    …..and be conservative in estimating losses, instead of bloating them.

  4. karun

    cannot believe this!

    look at what the editorial says and read the comments.

    Pakistan faces an uphill task, the average westerner is thoroughly disillusioned with Pakistan.

  5. Maryanne Khan

    The EU has just come on board with aid for Pakistan and a major bank, and with increased pledges from AUS and Japan, the UN says they’re almost half way to the goal.

    karun, not everyone is disillusioned, in time, hopefully, some sort of demonstration of will will emerge in Pakistan and the help will come in when there are actual projects to work on. Right now, with territory the size of Italy submerged it’s hard to know where to start. Let’s hope that regional leaders will devise plans for recovery and then we’ll all know what we’re doing. This can’t be fixed overnight, (although food and shelter relief is definitely needed overnight.)

    Has anyone put forward a concrete costing/reconstruction plan?

  6. shiv

    For all the angst about penny pinching by donors and how Pakistan is cash strapped I have noticed a wide variety of Pakistanis in the media who plainly lie about the Pakistani economy.

    No I am not saying Pakistan is not cash strapped – but Pakistanis in the media have consistently lied to project Pakistan as having a robust economy.
    A classic case in point is the Wikipedia article on “economy of Pakistan”. If you read that liar’s figures and actually do the math you find that the average Pakistan (aside from the wealthy and middle class) has an income of US $ minus 3500 a year. Yes $-3500.

    Why have Pakistanis bluffed themselves for years? When a Pakistani says something anyone in any responsible position in the world now realises that the Pakistani may be lying. What is the matter with Pakistanis?

  7. NSA

    Ah, Shiv I see what you mean.

    “Measured by purchasing power, Pakistan has a 30 million strong middle class, according to Dr. Ishrat Husain, Ex-Governor (2 December 1999 – 1 December 2005) of the State Bank of Pakistan.[30] It is a figure that correlates with research by Standard Chartered Bank which estimates that Pakistan possesses a “a middle class of 30 million people that Standard Chartered estimates now earn an average of about $10,000 a year.”[31] Latest figures put Pakistan’s Middle Class at 35 million strong.”

    So (being as conservative as possible) that is

    30 million * $10,000/annum = $300 billion/annum

    “In addition, Pakistan has a growing upper & upper middle class, which was estimated at 6.8 million in 2002[33] and has now grown to 17 million people as of 2010, with relatively high per capita incomes.”

    Again, being as conservative as possible, if the upper/upper middle class has an average of $20K per year, that is

    6.8 million * 20K/annum = $136 billion

    So we’ve accounted for $436 billion of Pakistan’s GDP, which is essentially all of it (Pakistan’s 2008 GDP was $431.2 billion PPP, as per Wiki).

    So about 130 million Pakistanis have zero or negative income.

  8. iamhere

    “Pakistan has suddenly become even more food insecure while being armed with nuclear weapons,” he says. Haider estimates it will be two years before the mainstream agricultural production cycle is back on track, “so people around the world are going to HAVE TO BE VERY GENEROUS to Pakistan”.


  9. Tilsim

    @ Maryanne Khan

    If I may say in Australian, a big ta to the Australian tax payer. We South Asians may have a few kangaroos loose in the top paddock from time to time but thanks for not letting that put you off!

    Australia’s contribution to Pakistan floods is significant and greatly appreciated. Australia does not have the historic cultural or religious ties with Pakistan so it’s particularly impressive in this regard.

  10. Midfield Dynamo

    Maryanne and Karun are sugar coating their beggar’s stance by suggesting it to be an endeavor to muster ‘Humanitarian Relief’, they are the type who actually mock at Pakistan’s destitution in the international community, compromise the pride of our poor masses by corrupting them with charitable donations.

    Pakistan must struggle to manage these hardships on its own, its leaders and the affluent should jump into the fray of the drowning, organize their rescue and manage the shelters, take your wealth to the people ___holes, you owe it to them, it is because of them that you drive those Porsches and Benzes, and live in those posh villas. Give some to the poor, and should you accept any donations from the international community, smear it on your face in shame and teach yourself and the beneficiaries that they owe a debt to the world, which must be paid back, not in the form of terror, but as grateful citizens in this global community.

  11. Bin Ismail

    @ Midfield Dynamo (August 19, 2010 at 11:38 pm)

    “…..and should you accept any donations from the international community, smear it on your face in shame and teach yourself and the beneficiaries that they owe a debt to the world, which must be paid back, not in the form of terror, but as grateful citizens in this global community…..”

    Very well said. As citizens of the global human community, what we owe the world most is a complete riddance of the scourge of militant mullaism and religious fanaticism.

    There is something we owe to Islam as well. This is to detach Islam and its blessed name from our un-Islamic politics.

    There is also something we owe to our own country – Pakistan. This is to run the country along the lines proposed by its founder, as a secular state.