In his article, Mr. Illyas has isolated Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, Allama Iqbal and Jinnah as the sources for Pakistan’s present ills and struggles with political Islam. Nothing could be farther from truth, atleast in the case of Sir Syed and Jinnah. Allama Iqbal’s importance as is is greatly over-emphasized in Pakistani history and Mr. Illyas’ comment about Iqbal shaping Jinnah’s ideas about statehood does not actually find any real resonance in real history. But then Illyas freely admits that his source is official Pakistani narrative as given by the Ziaist education system. Continue reading
Monthly Archives: June 2010
Shahid Illyas’s article “pakistan, islam and secularism” has to rank as one of the most superficial and naïve pieces on the idea of Pakistan and its interplay with Islam. It also underscores just how badly General Zia’s legacy has damaged the ability of the young Pakistani to think.